Erie, a city in northwestern Pennsylvania, is facing renewed economic strain following the cancellation of a major industrial initiative that was expected to revitalize its long-struggling manufacturing base. A startup, International Recycling Group (IRG), had planned to construct a $300 million facility aimed at converting plastic waste into fuel for steel production. The project promised hundreds of construction jobs and long-term employment, sparking hope among residents of the city’s under-resourced east side. However, the venture collapsed after the Department of Energy suspended a $182 million loan commitment, a move attributed to policy changes enacted early in Donald Trump’s latest term.
Drew Whiting, head of the Erie Downtown Development Corporation, described the setback as part of a broader pattern of disruption caused by federal decisions. His organization has led urban renewal efforts in one of the nation’s poorest zip codes, opening a food hall, new housing units, and commercial spaces. Their next mixed-use development could generate 100 jobs and contribute up to $10 million annually in tax revenue. Yet rising costs—labor and materials up by 37% since the beginning of the year—have complicated progress. Whiting cited a weakened dollar and labor shortages, exacerbated by stricter immigration enforcement, as key factors.
The abandoned paper mill site, once slated for IRG’s plant, now bears only a faded sign proclaiming “A recycling revolution is happening in Erie.” Environmental groups had opposed the project over concerns about pollution and potential contamination of Lake Erie. However, the Biden administration had prioritized such climate-focused initiatives, which made the loan approval last year a significant milestone. Trump’s executive order pausing federal disbursements halted the funding, leading IRG’s founder, Mitch Hecht, to announce the project’s cancellation.
Local nonprofits are also feeling the ripple effects. Second Harvest, Erie’s primary food bank, lost $1 million—about 25% of its annual budget—due to federal funding suspensions. Demand for food assistance has surged by 43% over the past few years, driven by inflation and the closure of local grocery stores. A prolonged budget impasse in the state legislature has further strained resources.
Business reactions to Trump’s economic strategy are mixed. While some, like Tom Tredway of Erie Molded Packaging, credit tax incentives from the One Big Beautiful Bill Act for a 15% sales increase and plans to expand, others face challenges. Farmer Roger Schultz reported declining profitability as tariffs reduced export interest from Canada and Mexico. He doubts trade will rebound quickly, noting structural shifts in international markets.
Supporters of the administration remain optimistic. Norm Francis, 81, a stained-glass repair business owner, blamed corporate greed for rising food prices but endorsed the tariffs as necessary. Retiree Sally Michalak, 73, linked immigration enforcement to inflation control, viewing government restructuring as a painful but essential step.
Gary Horton of the Urban Erie Community Development Corporation reflected on lost opportunities. His group repurposed a shuttered elementary school into a community garden, with hopes of reopening it if economic conditions improved—hopes tied in part to the success of the IRG plant. With that project gone, prospects dim, but Horton emphasized resilience: “We still have the challenge, and we still have the opportunity.”
— news from The Guardian
— News Original —
Pennsylvania city divided over Trump as it reels from economic whiplash
It was set to be the most expensive project that the beaten-down manufacturing sector of Erie, Pennsylvania, had seen in decades. In a blighted corner of town, a startup planned a $300m plant that would turn plastic waste into fuel for steel factories. n nNeighborhood advocates in Erie’s impoverished east side hoped the facility would provide the jobs and prosperity they needed. Environmentalists decried the pollution they expected the plant to bring. Unions got ready for what they hoped would be hundreds of jobs created by its construction, with more to come once it opened. n nAnd then it was over. Mitch Hecht, founder of the company pursuing the project, announced that a Department of Energy loan crucial to the plant’s funding was put on hold as a result of Donald Trump’s policies, which “had a severe and immediate impact on our ability to move forward”. n nIt was the latest bout of economic whiplash to strike the county on north-west Pennsylvania’s Lake Erie shoreline, just months after its voters helped return Trump to the White House. Those who backed the president say they are sticking with him, even as his administration’s spending cuts have upended projects and budgets and tariffs have created new uncertainties for businesses. n nOnce reliably Democratic at the presidential level, Erie county has emerged as hotly contested territory ever since 2016, when Trump became the first Republican to win the area in 32 years. Joe Biden carried the county by a slim 1,417 votes four years later, but it flipped back to Trump in 2024 by nearly the same margin. n n“We’re set up in this moment for extreme growth over the next 15, 20, 30 years, and as we try to just hobble off the starting line, we’re just getting whacked over the head by these larger macro policies and intentional immigration policies that create an inflation environment,” said Drew Whiting, CEO of the Erie Downtown Development Corporation. n nThe non-profit’s renovation efforts have helped open a food hall and new apartments and shops in what was once the poorest zip code in the US, and its latest project is a mixed-use space that could create 100 jobs and bring in up to $10m a year in tax revenue. But since the start of the year, costs of labor and materials have jumped 37%, which Whiting blamed on a dollar weakened by economic uncertainty, along with labor shortages worsened by Trump’s immigration crackdown. n nA short drive from downtown, a placard reading: “A recycling revolution is happening in Erie” standing outside a long-shuttered paper mill is the only sign remaining of the plastic waste facility that the startup International Recycling Group (IRG) planned to build there. n nThough environmental groups warned IRG’s plant would create more pollution and lead to garbage filling Lake Erie, projects intended to fight the climate crisis and address long-running problems such as how to dispose of plastic waste were priorities of the Biden administration, and last year, IRG announced it had received a $182m loan commitment from the energy department. n nOn his first day in office, Trump signed an executive order that paused disbursements of such funds, and by April of this year, Hecht had announced that the loan had been put on hold, and the project would be canceled. IRG did not respond to a request for comment, and the Department of Energy did not respond to an email sent during the government shutdown. n nRailing against “waste, fraud and abuse” in Washington, Trump has put on hold numerous federal programs. Erie’s food bank, Second Harvest, has lost $1m that would go towards food purchasing, or about 25% of their budget, due to such funding cuts, its CEO, Gregory Hall, said. n nMeanwhile, need for their assistance has only grown, climbing 43% in the past two to three years as food prices rose and local grocers went under. A deadlock in the state legislature over approving a budget, which began in July, has only worsened the financial situation. n
“It has been a plethora of different funding cuts, different programs canceled, that is truly having an impact on not only the amount of food, but the types and quality of food that we can provide to the neighbors in our region,” Hall said. n nTrump’s solution to the ills plaguing communities like Erie is tariffs, which he says will encourage businesses to bring jobs back to the US from overseas, and protect domestic manufacturers from foreign competition. Businesses are divided over how significant the levies are, and whether the turmoil they have brought will be worth it. n n“It’s greatly impacted profitability, but it’s also it’s leading to the product not getting harvested,” said Roger Schultz, a farmer outside Erie who said his largest markets for apples, Canada and Mexico, are far less interested in taking his crop this year because of the levies. n nHe was skeptical that the president’s promises of new trade deals would lead to those markets reopening. n n“Fundamental changes have happened out there in the marketplace, and no amount of pleading or price cutting or, ‘Hey, won’t you try this,’ is going to get you back in that,” Schultz said. n nAt the injection plastic firm Erie Molded Packaging, sales have risen 15% this year, and its president, Tom Tredway, said he is looking at expanding their factory, thanks in part to tax deductions for businesses included in Trump and the GOP’s One Big Beautiful Bill Act. While all of their suppliers and customers are in the US, the thin-gauge aluminum that is used in liners for their plastic containers is manufactured abroad, and tariffs have driven the prices higher. n n“It’s a nuisance more than anything,” he said. n nJezree Friend, vice-president of the Manufacturer and Business Association, an Erie-based advocacy and training group, described the higher costs as a necessary evil. n n“It’s a growing pain that gets you now. I think a lot of the business owners recognize that and are actually OK with that, by what they’re telling me,” he said. n nWhen Second Harvest distributes groceries, people line up in their cars hours early out of concern that the food on hand may run out. Those who supported the president on a recent Wednesday said they were pleased with what he had done so far. n n“I think he stands up for the people. I think he’s doing right,” said Norm Francis, 81, who runs a business fixing stained glass. “Corporate greed”, he said, was to blame for food prices that had become increasingly unaffordable for him, but the tariffs were “the right thing to do”. n nAhead of him in line was Sally Michalak, 73, a retiree who was counting on Trump’s deportation campaign to curb inflation. n n“He’s getting rid of the illegals, so once all that settles down, I think grocery prices will go down,” she said. n nAs for his funding cuts, Michalak shrugged them off as a necessary component of transforming a government she viewed as broken. n n“It’s just one of these deals where, if the house burns down, you have to tear it down completely before you rebuild it, and that’s what he’s doing,” she said. n nRebuilding was on the mind of Gary Horton, executive director of the Urban Erie Community Development Corporation, as he sat in the gymnasium of a shuttered elementary school not far from where IRG would have built its plant. Closed in 2012 as enrollment in the neighborhoods around it declined, the Burton school has been used by local police for active shooter drills that have left paint splatter on the walls and bullet casings on the floor. n nTwo years ago, Horton’s group bought it and turned the grounds into a community garden, with plans to hopefully reopen the school if the neighborhood’s economy turned around, hopefully with the help of the plastics plant. n n“The success of it would have helped us here, but it would have also helped maybe cultivate an atmosphere where other developers or other owners of projects would do the same thing,” Horton said. n nNow that the project has been canceled, “the odds of doing something right now aren’t great,” Horton conceded. “But we still have the challenge, and we still have the opportunity.”